-1 to be honest with you Air: For the past few days your behavior has been borderline mingey.

• Repeated micspmaming (mostly consisting of playing SexyBack) as you fly around in restricted areas.

• Ongoing OOC text about player's distaste for your actions, sometimes even arguments.

• Frequent complaining regarding balance changes when they don't benefit you.

• Repeated provoking of the Empire in attempts to get into combat with them.

• Continuously break NLR and when told you can't be on base and the recent response is that you are doing mail runs? Not only is it breaking the roleplay immersion it's a terrible excuse, I recommend switching jobs if you need to do them that badly to something that has access to base.

• I also find it irresponsible that you prematurely retired from your job as Governor Pryce that you held for approximately a little over 24 hours, I assume because your presumptuous and believed you were a shoe in for Maul.

• On the topic of that you slightly guilt trip people who even have mentioned going for Maul or just in general saying that you resigned from your Governor job for it, no one told you to do that, that was a choice you made and it feels manipulative.

• Also the vote for Air spam gifs become excessive and irritating when they're placed in chats like the suggestions.

The application itself doesn't seem terrible besides quite a few grammatical and spelling errors however your behavior on the server has just been a lot to say the least.

With that being said you've been building support but I believe it'll come from being persistent as oppose to it feeling earned via roleplay but that's my take on it, best of luck to you but you would've definitely had my support until I watched your actions the last few days as mostly Boba Fett, it's been extremely upsetting to see you act this way and I don't think you'd be fit for Maul until your actions improve. Whether you get it or not I hope you take this as a reflection on what your actions may appear to be to another player as oppose to this as an attack on you, it's not just my perception of events.

I cannot speak as to the criticisms of supposed minginess, unfair complaints, and the Governor situation. However, I can attest to my personal experiences with Meraki in his capacity as Boba Fett. In his capacity as Boba Fett, he has actively engaged in civilian and criminal rp, specifically that of SK7 which I play a large part in running, and has had a genuine beneficial impact on our rp. For these reasons, I am in support of this application. I think that for the purpose Maul will serve on the server, he will do a good job.

Seb | Strict - I Fully understand where you are coming from. Yes for the first start I was miningy and not that much into RP. I have spoken with players I have trolled and fixed it. I do hope within the week of applications That you see I have changed in terms of RP and all the other -1's you see. I have for a day / 2 days been Rping and Hope to get some RP with you as well! Also Would like to add, I am not trying to manipulate or anything of what you’re suggesting. I simply stepped down because Mom would be a better fit for me and I made that clear with higher ups and said I was sorry. I also did stop spamming the gift because it was. Spamming and I am sorry it irritated you. I will be working on everything you said even if I was already! Thank you again!

Leaning +1

While most of my interactions with Meraki as boba fett ( as Finis Valorum) have all been very in character and serious, I know there's plenty of times when he hasn't been, but he shows the capability of being able to be in character. The application is grammatically not that great, but its content, is great, could use a bit of work but its most definitely satisfactory and goes beyond requirements. Meraki may have been mingy the past few days but I know he has it in him to be serious, and to act as a good Maul. There's a very interesting balance that needs to be done, so if you were "Overseen" by someone that is experienced in this field of Civ/Criminal RP, I would see you being a great Maul!

I won't lie, I've Known air for a good couple months, he's an excellent roleplayer when he wants to be. The way he portrayed fett in the beginning was mingy, but as Shock SGT Signal, I can confirm that Air as boba has become a welcome rp interaction. We've made lore together, we've created scenarios that could be considered accurate. I vote air for Maul, Personally.

I believe that Strict is very valid in his criticisms of you. However I think we tend to forget that beneath the dark atmosphere of the Empire, this server is still Semi-Serious. It’s perfectly fine to be goofy as long as it’s tasteful. A criticism I do disagree with, however, is that you are causing problems by PvPing with Imperial players. In my eyes, this is a good thing, especially since Maul and the entirety of SC’s main focus is going to be PvP against us. When you introduce opposing factions like this, you have to also understand that combat rules are ever-changing and you must be able to flow with them.

Instead of using this to criticize you or berate you, I will use this as a chance to give you some advice. As a leader, you don’t only represent yourself, but your entire faction. Your public image is everything. This means building IC and OOC relations with those around you, and taking the time to read and rewrite your words and statements to ensure that they are grammatically correct. If you’re unsure of how a word is spelled, then look it up or contact someone you trust to proof-read and give input. You have to be able to present yourself as something more than what you actually are. Be yourself, of course, but try your best to be a better version of yourself.

You must be more serious than others, and more dutiful. Those below you will look to you as a role-model, so you have to BE exactly what you preach.

I’m 100% willing to give you a chance in this role, but there are things that need to be improved, specifically with your public image. If you are ever in need of advice from a leadership perspective, my DMs are always open.

-1

This is kind of a mix of what has already been said.

I have only seen you engage in a serious RP manner when you were playing a droid and interacting with Nova. I don't see you play any Imperial jobs long enough to experience any sort of memorable roleplay from you because you quickly resigned from Governor, and hopped on a ST whitelist once just to spam music through your mic. While it is a good thing to promote PVP against the Empire, your main method is by constantly going into restricted areas you know you can't enter, and then getting upset when you're getting shot at or told to leave. This does not promote PVP or good roleplay, it's provocative behavior to get a reaction out of people.

I think the "vote Air for Maul" gifs can actually be used as fun propaganda. What does bother me, however, is that you declared that you would do "3 T4 giveaways" if you get picked for Maul. You have been kind enough to randomly donate things to other people in the server before, but, when you claim that you will do it again only after you get picked for the leader of a faction, it sounds like borderline bribery.

I'm sorry for bringing this back up, but I feel I have to so I can give clarity on what I am trying to say with this. You originally made your Governor application with the use of AI, and then carelessly resigned from the position right after launch with no successor, no plans, because you quickly changed your mind and decided that you want to be Maul. This displays a serious lack of responsibility and effort into what you are trying to do. You are persistent, but that persistence does not carry weight if there is no passion behind the project.

I can see that when you do put your mind into actually roleplaying, you can be good at it. But, considering your behavior and other factors, I do not feel comfortable seeing you run Shadow Collective as Maul.

I apologize if this came off as harsh. And I do hope that you take this criticism and use it to improve.

Carmen

• thank you so much for your feedback! I’m trying to reply to everyone that gives a -1 to explain or thank them so I can improve and hopefully get maul! What seems to be the biggest concern is the lack of RP you’ve seen from me and the way I just threw away the governor position. As I’ve stated before, I was trolling around a good bit when I was first in the server. After I learned more details about the job I really wanted. I started getting more into RP as you can tell from some of the other responses. And I am still getting more into RP. And I did not just throw away the governor position. I thought it wasn’t the best suited with the other positions that were available. And I did resign from that position by talking to target first and everything of the sorts as I did not just drop it. Now from the mic spamming I was actually are peeing a speaker, but as you can tell from one point of view to the other, it kind of gets displayed wrong. And about the bribery situation that is completely wrong. This is not bribery or propaganda. I was just doing that to campaign to be making it a little fun and the giveaway. I’m doing that no matter what if I get it or not. THANK YOU again!!!!

Neutral

Costco took the words out of my mouth.

All of my interactions with you were mostly killing you as Boba or on your Clap Trap character which was more or less just a goofy droid. I haven’t had the chance to “roleplay” with you properly, I suppose.

Strict also noted the whole running around as an ST micspamming which I did see and thought was incredibly inappropriate.

People have their moments, but I just cannot give you a +1. I want to believe you can do this so I won’t-1 you either. You just need to keep it together and do some good roleplay and ball. You know?